What is Synthetic Fraud?

Synthetic identity fraud is a type of fraud in which criminals create fake identities by combining real and fictitious information. Unlike traditional identity theft, where an individual's existing personal information is stolen and misused, synthetic identity fraud involves the fabrication of entirely new identities.

Here's how it typically works:

1. Creation of Synthetic Identity: Fraudsters begin by combining real and fake information, such as a legitimate Social Security number (often obtained from children or individuals with no credit history) with fabricated names, addresses, and other details.
   
   
2. Building Credit Profiles: Once the synthetic identity is established, fraudsters work to build a credit history for it. They may apply for small lines of credit, such as store credit cards, and make timely payments to establish a positive credit history.
   
   
3. Credit Expansion: Over time, as the synthetic identity's credit history grows, fraudsters apply for larger lines of credit, such as credit cards and loans, using the fabricated identity.
   
   
4. Monetisation: Once significant credit has been obtained, fraudsters "bust out" the synthetic identity by maxing out credit lines and disappearing without making payments, leaving behind a trail of debt.

Synthetic identity fraud is particularly challenging to detect and prevent because the identities used are often a blend of real and fake information, making it difficult for traditional identity verification methods to flag them as fraudulent. Additionally, because the fraudsters typically start with small lines of credit and gradually build up, their activities may go unnoticed for extended periods.

This type of fraud can have significant financial implications for both individuals and financial institutions, as it can result in substantial losses and damage to credit profiles. It requires a multifaceted approach involving improved identity verification techniques, enhanced fraud detection systems, and collaboration among financial institutions, regulators, and law enforcement agencies to effectively combat it.

How does Synthetic Identity Fraud Differ from Traditional Identity Theft?

Synthetic identity fraud differs from traditional identity theft in several key ways:

1. Creation of Identity: In traditional identity theft, the fraudster steals an individual's existing personal information, such as their Social Security number, name, date of birth, and other identifying details. In synthetic identity fraud, the fraudster fabricates an entirely new identity by combining real and fictitious information. This may involve using a legitimate Social Security number obtained from various sources along with fabricated names, addresses, and other details.
   
   
2. Detection Difficulty: Traditional identity theft involves the unauthorised use of an individual's established identity, making it relatively easier to detect through identity verification processes and monitoring for suspicious activity. Synthetic identity fraud, on the other hand, can be more challenging to detect because the fabricated identities may not match any existing records, and the fraudsters gradually build up credit profiles over time, often starting with small lines of credit and making timely payments to establish legitimacy.
   
   
3. Financial Impact: Both types of fraud can have significant financial implications for victims and financial institutions. However, synthetic identity fraud can be more damaging in some cases because it may involve larger lines of credit and can result in substantial losses for creditors when the fraudsters "bust out" by maxing out credit lines and disappearing without making payments. Additionally, synthetic identity fraud can be more difficult to recover from because the fabricated identities may remain active even after the fraud is discovered, potentially leading to ongoing issues with credit reports and scores.
   
   
4. Regulatory Response: Recognising the growing threat posed by synthetic identity fraud, regulators and financial institutions have been taking steps to address the issue, such as implementing enhanced identity verification measures, improving fraud detection systems, and promoting information sharing and collaboration among industry stakeholders. While traditional identity theft also faces regulatory scrutiny and countermeasures, synthetic identity fraud presents unique challenges that require targeted solutions.

Overall, while both traditional identity theft and synthetic identity fraud involve the misuse of personal information for fraudulent purposes, the methods, and implications of each differ, necessitating tailored approaches to detection, prevention, and mitigation.

How do Perpetrators Create Synthetic Identities?

Perpetrators create synthetic identities by combining real and fictitious information to fabricate entirely new identities. Here's a general overview of the steps involved in creating synthetic identities:

1. Obtaining Real Information: Perpetrators typically start by acquiring legitimate personal information that can be used to construct the synthetic identity. This may include Social Security numbers (SSNs) obtained from various sources, such as children, individuals with no credit history, or stolen SSNs from data breaches.
   
   
2. Generating Fictitious Information: Once they have a legitimate SSN, perpetrators create fabricated identities by combining it with fictitious names, addresses, dates of birth, and other details. They may use random combinations of information or create identities that mimic real individuals but are entirely fictitious.
   
   
3. Establishing Credit Profiles: With the synthetic identity created, perpetrators work to build credit profiles for these identities. They may start with small lines of credit, such as store credit cards or secured loans, and make timely payments to establish a positive credit history. This gradual approach helps avoid suspicion and improves the chances of obtaining larger lines of credit in the future.
   
   
4. Expanding Credit: As the synthetic identity's credit history grows, perpetrators apply for larger lines of credit, such as traditional credit cards, auto loans, or mortgages, using the fabricated identity. They may continue to make payments on these accounts to maintain the appearance of legitimacy.
   
   
5. Monetisation: Once significant credit has been obtained, perpetrators "bust out" the synthetic identity by maxing out credit lines and disappearing without making payments. This leaves behind a trail of debt and can result in substantial losses for creditors.

It's important to note that creating synthetic identities requires a combination of skill, patience, and access to personal information. Perpetrators may use various methods to obtain the necessary information, including data breaches, social engineering tactics, and purchasing data on the dark web. Additionally, they often take steps to evade detection by using different addresses, phone numbers, and other details associated with the synthetic identities.

What are the Warning Signs of Synthetic Identity Fraud?

Detecting synthetic identity fraud can be challenging due to the complex and evolving nature of the fraud. However, there are several warning signs that individuals, businesses, and financial institutions can watch for:

1. New Credit Applicants with Limited History: Synthetic identities often start with minimal or no credit history. Be cautious of credit applications from individuals with limited or non-existent credit profiles.
   
   
2. Incomplete or Inconsistent Information: Synthetic identities may have incomplete or inconsistent information, such as mismatched addresses, variations in names or dates of birth, or unusual Social Security number formats. Pay attention to discrepancies in the information provided on credit applications or account documents.
   
   
3. High-Risk Addresses or Phone Numbers: Synthetic identities may be associated with high-risk addresses, such as mail drops or vacant properties, or phone numbers that are disconnected or associated with multiple identities.
   
   
4. Unusual Spending Patterns: Monitor for unusual spending patterns or activity on accounts associated with synthetic identities, such as rapid accumulation of debt, frequent changes in purchasing behaviour, or purchases inconsistent with the individual's profile.
   
   
5. Identity Document Discrepancies: Synthetic identities may be associated with counterfeit or altered identity documents, such as fake driver's licenses or Social Security cards. Verify the authenticity of identity documents presented during the application process.
   
   
6. Synthetic Credit Profiles: Be wary of credit profiles that appear artificially constructed, with a sudden influx of new accounts or a rapid increase in credit limits. Synthetic identities often exhibit patterns of credit utilisation and payment behaviour that differ from legitimate consumers.
   
   
7. Identity Theft Alerts: Keep an eye on identity theft alerts or notifications from credit monitoring services indicating suspicious activity or unauthorized access to personal information.
   
   
8. Unusual Credit Inquiries: Monitor credit reports for unusual or unauthorized inquiries from lenders or creditors, which may indicate attempts to establish synthetic identities using your personal information.
   
   
9. Account Takeover Attempts: Be vigilant for signs of account takeover attempts, such as unauthorized changes to account information or unusual account activity, which may be indicative of synthetic identity fraud.
   
   
10. Fraudulent Applications Detected by Fraud Detection Systems: Utilise fraud detection systems and algorithms to flag potentially fraudulent credit applications or account openings based on anomalous behaviour, patterns, or discrepancies.

It's essential to implement robust identity verification processes, fraud detection systems, and monitoring mechanisms to detect and prevent synthetic identity fraud effectively. Additionally, maintaining awareness of emerging fraud trends and collaborating with industry partners and law enforcement agencies can help enhance detection and mitigation efforts.

What are the Impacts of Synthetic Identity Fraud on Individuals and Businesses?

Synthetic identity fraud can have significant impacts on both individuals and businesses:

1. Financial Losses: Individuals affected by synthetic identity fraud may face financial losses resulting from fraudulent charges, unauthorised loans, or other fraudulent transactions made using their personal information. In some cases, victims may be held liable for debts incurred by synthetic identities created using their information, leading to financial hardship and damage to credit scores.
   
   
2. Credit Damage: Synthetic identity fraud can result in damage to victims' credit profiles and scores. Fraudulent accounts and unpaid debts associated with synthetic identities can negatively impact victims' creditworthiness, making it difficult to obtain loans, mortgages, or other forms of credit in the future.
   
   
3. Emotional Stress: Discovering that one's personal information has been used to create synthetic identities and commit fraud can be emotionally distressing for victims. It can lead to feelings of violation, betrayal, anxiety, and uncertainty about the extent of the fraud and its potential long-term consequences.
   
   
4. Identity Theft Fallout: Victims of synthetic identity fraud may experience the fallout of identity theft, including the time and effort required to dispute fraudulent accounts, repair credit damage, and restore their identities. This process can be lengthy, complex, and frustrating, requiring victims to navigate bureaucratic red tape and work with credit bureaus, financial institutions, and law enforcement agencies.
   
   
5. Reputational Damage: Businesses targeted by synthetic identity fraud may suffer reputational damage due to association with fraudulent activity and data breaches. Customer trust and loyalty can be undermined if businesses fail to adequately protect customer information or respond effectively to security breaches.
   
   
6. Financial Institution Losses: Financial institutions and lenders can incur significant losses as a result of synthetic identity fraud, including unpaid debts, chargebacks, and fraudulent claims. Synthetic identities can be used to exploit loopholes in identity verification and credit scoring systems, leading to increased fraud losses and operational costs for financial institutions.
   
   
7. Regulatory Scrutiny and Fines: Businesses may face regulatory scrutiny and potential fines for failing to comply with data protection regulations or adequately safeguard customer information. Regulatory agencies may investigate security breaches and impose penalties for violations, further impacting the financial and reputational health of affected businesses.
   
   
8. Market Instability: Synthetic identity fraud can contribute to market instability and economic uncertainty by undermining confidence in financial systems and institutions. High levels of fraud can erode trust in the integrity of credit markets and consumer lending, potentially leading to tighter lending standards, reduced access to credit, and slower economic growth.

Overall, synthetic identity fraud poses significant risks and challenges for individuals, businesses, and financial institutions, highlighting the importance of implementing robust security measures, fraud detection systems, and identity verification processes to mitigate the impact of fraud and protect against future attacks.

What Industries are Most Susceptible to Synthetic Identity Fraud?

Synthetic identity fraud can target various industries, but some sectors are more susceptible due to the nature of their operations, the type of data they handle, and the services they provide. Here are some industries that are particularly vulnerable to synthetic identity fraud:

1. Financial Services: Financial institutions, including banks, credit unions, and lenders, are prime targets for synthetic identity fraud due to the potential financial rewards associated with fraudulent loans, credit cards, and other financial products. Synthetic identities can exploit vulnerabilities in identity verification and credit scoring systems to obtain loans, open accounts, and engage in fraudulent transactions.
   
   
2. Retail: Retailers, especially those offering store credit cards and instalment payment options, are attractive targets for synthetic identity fraud. Fraudsters may use synthetic identities to make fraudulent purchases, apply for credit accounts, and exploit promotional offers and discounts.
   
   
3. Telecommunications: Telecommunications companies are susceptible to synthetic identity fraud, particularly in cases involving fraudulent mobile phone activations, subscription services, and equipment financing. Fraudsters may use synthetic identities to obtain mobile phones, internet services, and other telecommunications products without intending to pay for them.
   
   
4. Healthcare: The healthcare industry is increasingly targeted by synthetic identity fraudsters seeking to exploit vulnerabilities in patient registration, billing, and insurance claims processes. Synthetic identities may be used to obtain medical services, prescription drugs, and medical equipment fraudulently, leading to financial losses and compromised patient data.
   
   
5. Government Services: Government agencies and services, such as social welfare programs, public assistance, and immigration services, are vulnerable to synthetic identity fraud. Fraudsters may use synthetic identities to fraudulently access government benefits, obtain fraudulent identification documents, or engage in other forms of identity theft.
   
   
6. Online Marketplaces: E-commerce platforms and online marketplaces are susceptible to synthetic identity fraud, particularly in cases involving fraudulent account creation, payment fraud, and identity theft. Fraudsters may use synthetic identities to set up fake seller accounts, make fraudulent purchases, and engage in other forms of online fraud.
   
   
7. Insurance: Insurance companies and providers are targeted by synthetic identity fraudsters seeking to obtain fraudulent insurance policies, submit false claims, and commit insurance fraud. Synthetic identities may be used to obtain auto insurance, health insurance, life insurance, and other types of insurance coverage fraudulently.
   
   
8. Fintech and Digital Banking: Fintech companies and digital banking platforms are increasingly targeted by synthetic identity fraudsters seeking to exploit vulnerabilities in online account opening, mobile banking, and digital payment systems. Synthetic identities may be used to open online accounts, apply for digital loans, and engage in other forms of financial fraud.

Overall, any industry that handles sensitive personal information, offers financial products or services or relies on identity verification processes is susceptible to synthetic identity fraud. To mitigate the risk of fraud, organisations must implement robust security measures, fraud detection systems, and identity verification processes to protect against synthetic identity fraud and other forms of financial crime.

Top of Form

How can Electronic Identity Combat Synthetic Identity Fraud?

Electronic identity (eID) verification can play a crucial role in combating synthetic identity fraud by leveraging digital technologies to verify the identity of individuals remotely and securely. Here are several ways electronic identity verification can help combat synthetic identity fraud:

1. Biometric Authentication: Biometric authentication methods, such as fingerprint scans, facial recognition, or iris scans, can be used to verify the identity of individuals based on unique physical characteristics. Biometric data is difficult to fake or replicate, making it a robust authentication method for preventing synthetic identity fraud.
   
   
2. Document Verification: Electronic identity verification solutions can utilise advanced document verification techniques to authenticate identity documents, such as driver's licenses, passports, or national identification cards. These solutions can analyse document images for authenticity, detect alterations or counterfeits, and extract relevant information for identity verification purposes.
   
   
3. Identity Verification Services: ID verification services utilise a combination of data sources, such as credit bureaus, government databases, and public records, to verify the identity of individuals electronically. These services can perform real-time checks on personal information, such as names, addresses, Social Security numbers, and date of birth, to validate the authenticity of identities and detect potential synthetic identity fraud.
   
   
4. Machine Learning and AI: Machine learning algorithms and artificial intelligence (AI) technologies can be employed to analyse patterns, behaviours, and anomalies associated with identity verification processes. These algorithms can identify suspicious activities, inconsistencies, or deviations from normal behaviour that may indicate synthetic identity fraud.
   
   
5. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Multi-factor authentication combines multiple authentication factors, such as something the user knows (e.g., passwords), something they have (e.g., mobile phones), and something they are (e.g., biometric data), to verify the identity of individuals more securely. Implementing MFA can enhance the security of electronic identity verification processes and reduce the risk of synthetic identity fraud.
   
   
6. Blockchain Technology: Blockchain technology offers secure and tamper-proof identity management solutions that can help combat synthetic identity fraud. Blockchain-based identity platforms enable individuals to maintain control over their identity information, share it securely with trusted parties, and prevent unauthorized access or tampering with personal data.
   
   
7. Real-Time Monitoring and Alerts: Electronic identity verification systems can provide real-time monitoring and alerts for suspicious activities, unusual behaviours, or potential fraud indicators. These systems can flag anomalies and trigger alerts for further investigation, helping organisations detect and mitigate synthetic identity fraud in real time.

By leveraging electronic identity verification technologies and solutions, organisations can strengthen their identity verification processes, enhance security measures, and combat synthetic identity fraud more effectively. However, it's essential to implement a layered approach to identity verification, combining multiple authentication methods and techniques to provide robust protection against evolving fraud threats.